Sanibel Island Luxury Rentals - Vacation Rentals in The Windmill Farm & Craft Market

Dates

Price

Guests

More

When do you want to travel?

We search multiple sites to find you the best prices.

Compare Price with Other Partners

From US $469

         

10.0 (11 Reviews)

House

Edgewater Escape - Beautifully Remodeled Cottage on Keuka's East Side!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• New York
• Penn Yan

View Availability

From US $235

         

|

9.5 (33 Reviews)

House

Heated & AC Full Bathroom Covered Wagon

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• Penn Yan

View Availability

From US $211

         

9.6 (55 Reviews)

House

Cedar Lane Cabin: Authentic log cabin in wooded setting overlooking rural farmland

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Balcony/Terrace

• Penn Yan
• Town of Milo

View Availability

From US $316

         

|

9.0 (11 Reviews)

House

Heated & AC Yurt

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• Penn Yan

View Availability

From US $689

         

10.0 (95 Reviews)

House

Updated Open Plan - Keuka Lakefront Home 4BR & 157' private beach

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• Penn Yan

View Availability

From US $144

         

|

5.5 (12 Reviews)

House

Rustic Ridge

• Parking
• Pet Friendly
• Balcony/Terrace

• New York
• Penn Yan

View Availability

From US $853

         

10.0 (34 Reviews)

House

Westerly on Keuka Lake

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• New York
• Penn Yan

View Availability

From US $654

         

10.0 (17 Reviews)

House

TreeTops, modern luxury overlooking Keuka Lake - luxury Treehouse new for 2025!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• Penn Yan

View Availability

From US $233

         

10.0 (13 Reviews)

House

Beautiful home in wine country w/deck, peaceful views & close to town

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Penn Yan
• Town of Milo

View Availability

From US $535

         

10.0 (11 Reviews)

House

On Cloud Wine: lake home on Keuka Lake`s east side, private beachfront

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Penn Yan
• Town of Milo

View Availability

From US $380

         

10.0 (7 Reviews)

House

The Cabin At Keuka Lake-Great Views overlooking the Lake!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Penn Yan
• Town of Milo

View Availability

From US $674

         

10.0 (6 Reviews)

House

Beautiful Keuka Lake Home close to Penn Yan

• Air Conditioner
• Balcony/Terrace
• Security/Safety

• New York
• Penn Yan

View Availability

From US $233

         

10.0 (3 Reviews)

House

Cozy 1 Bed, 1 Bath Smart Home Capsule on Scenic Keuka Wine Trail–Modern Comfort!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• Penn Yan

View Availability

From US $231

         

10.0 (3 Reviews)

Apartment

Home w/Lake Views on Finger Lakes Wine Trail

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Penn Yan
• Town of Milo

View Availability

From US $210

         

10.0 (2 Reviews)

Cabin

Finger Lakes Pondside Haven

• Air Conditioner
• Bedding/Linens
• Wellness Facilities

• New York
• Dundee

View Availability

From US $2,053

         

10.0 (1 Review)

House

NEW LISTING 5 BR/3 BA Authentic Luxury Home ON Keuka Lake!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• Valois

View Availability

From US $223

         

9.8 (68 Reviews)

Cabin

Cozy, rustic cabin with beautiful views, privacy, and 1 mile from Keuka Lake

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Balcony/Terrace

• New York
• Valois

View Availability

From US $196

         

9.6 (152 Reviews)

Cabin

Cozy, rustic cabin with beautiful views, privacy and 1 mile from Keuka Lake

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Balcony/Terrace

• New York
• Penn Yan

View Availability

From US $205

         

9.6 (128 Reviews)

House

Morning Dove-Seneca/Keuka-Countryside-Hot Tub-WineTrail-Pets, Scenic Wooded Lot-Babbling Brook

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• Penn Yan
• Town of Milo

View Availability

From US $208

         

9.6 (97 Reviews)

House

Sunflower-Keuka/Seneca-Lake View-Hot Tub-Wine Trail-Pets, 13 Wooded Acres-7 min to Beach

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• Penn Yan

View Availability

From US $182

         

9.6 (28 Reviews)

House

Pet Friendly Keuka Yurt

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• New York
• Penn Yan

View Availability

From US $156

         

9.6 (25 Reviews)

House

Pet Friendly Keuka Wagon

• Child Friendly

• New York
• Penn Yan

View Availability

From US $151

         

9.4 (55 Reviews)

House

Pet Friendly Log Cabin

• Parking
• Pet Friendly
• View

• New York
• Penn Yan

View Availability

From US $425

         

9.2 (10 Reviews)

House

Lakefront | Dock | Keuka Lake | Near Wineries

• Air Conditioner
• Pet Friendly
• TV

• New York
• Valois

View Availability

★ Pro Tip: Sanibelislandluxuryrentals makes it easy to compare the best listings on Sanibelislandluxuryrentals homes from online vacation rental OTAs, including Booking.com and more. Use the Advanced Filter feature at the top to easily flip between Sanibelislandluxuryrentals homes, vacation rentals, bed and breakfasts, private Airbnb-style rentals availability, eco-friendly properties, property type, cancellation policies, prices, and several different options. All these make it easier to find the perfect accommodation for your next vacation in The Windmill Farm & Craft Market.